Here are the feedback types available for this presentation:
-
Pips
Answer a series of directed questions about specific design elements on each screen.
-
Thumb Rating
A thumb rating is good for giving a gut reaction about whether you think the screen is good or not.
-
Leave a Comment
Tell us why you gave it a thumbs up or down.
On Mozilla Is
It was mentioned in the meeting that relying on an image that requires 3 categories might limit us as this number may change.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla Is
Sean visually voted a thumbs up
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla Is
Ask during pictures possibly
Brandon Arnold about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla + You
Getting to tangible examples of the How you can help make the internet better would be awesome.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Fun Facts
Watch for messaging on these
Brandon Arnold about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla + You
Get to tangible examples early
Brandon Arnold about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla Story
I like that this puts our existance in context and that it's concrete
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Who, What we do, What we make
Separating non-profit and corporation might be too much information to the end user. They may care more about what we do, rather than our organization architecture.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Who, What we do, What we make
Intentional to not understand difference that is different from the non-profit and the corporation.
Brandon Arnold about 10 years ago
EditOn Who, What we do, What we make
Mo-Fo is the same as Mo-Co
Brandon Arnold about 10 years ago
EditOn Who, What we do, What we make
I like this as a way of organzing what we do
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Pillars
this is a really "on the nose" approach but maybe straightforward is good?
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Changing Word
We've talked about executing something similar among ourselves. Would love to explore more.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Values
I like this but I wonder if we are overlapping the Manifesto? I'd like to see this explored so we can figure if it works- skeptical as talkng about OURSELVES is tired and we need to do a better job making clear what shared values
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Changing Word
Web Literacy
Brandon Arnold about 10 years ago
EditOn Video and Impactful Headline
I don't love using videos to tell stories online, but I think that might just be my personal bias.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Changing Word
Craig brings up a good point about localization, but still good to explore.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Changing Word
I like- I wonder how this can be market specific and not requiring sentence structure.
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Multimedia Feed
We need this.
Sean about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla, Mozillians, and You
We've seen on mozilla.org/contribute that people who read the stories are more likely to give us their email address to learn more aobut joinng the community.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Video and Impactful Headline
Videos, again, present l10n problems.
Craig about 10 years ago
EditOn Multimedia Feed
Thumbs up if we can maintain this and when doing so in an automatic way, ensure that our vision is clear.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Video and Impactful Headline
Further: videos are great for slice-of-life, tone-setting stuff, but not necessarily for really essential content. Think of videos as long photos, supporting text without replacing it.
Craig about 10 years ago
EditOn Global
Very similar to Web We Want - do we reskin and embed into main site?
Sean about 10 years ago
EditOn Global
Web Health Reportish?
Sean about 10 years ago
EditOn Principles throughout
I like that becuase it might let us surface what activities are manifestations of each principle.
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Principles throughout
a match game!
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Principle through Mozillian's voice
meh
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Global
this would be helpful to making it feel global. might be hard to wrangle?
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Global
I have a bias against maps - they are political and can get us in trouble. We are very open to using geolocation however to offer geo-specific content in addition to conditional content by locale.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Global
Accompany issues with an action that the user can take.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Similar Topics
LIke.
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Similar Topics
Not sure we will have enough content for satisfying recommendations?
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Similar Topics
lets us create a continuity of experience and explicit connection between our activities
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Region Specific Seciton
This content would be hard to curate and keep fresh.
Craig about 10 years ago
EditOn Success Stories
What we've been apart of not just what we did.
Brandon Arnold about 10 years ago
EditOn Success Stories
this weaker for me.
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Success Stories
...from a content/story perspective
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Infographic of Outcomes
also weaker as we can't take alot of credit for stuff. we need to find ways to take credit for our work
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Following the Issues - Timeline
this feels alot slike the infographic in the earlier example. I'd liek to see this go into the future.
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Changing Word
This is weaker for me but a good potential for low barrier to entry for contribuiton/participation
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Talking about the Issues
This is good way to surface conversations
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Connect with a Mozillian
This is a big ask in terms of organizing people to be the "mentors."
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Connect with a Mozillian
this feels too tight.
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Easy to Share Graphics
https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/contribute/friends/
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Easy to Share Graphics
We are using a "word of mouth program" vendor who might have a feed ^
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Connect with a Mozillian
If they connect with a Mozillian... we should arm the Mozillians with tasks that can be shared during the conversation that can be quantified. For example... the end of the conversation could result in sharing a petition to sign or fun task.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Infographic of Outcomes
Also something had to keep fresh. If all our accomplishments are from two years ago, people will ask what we've done lately.
Craig about 10 years ago
EditOn Connect with a Mozillian
Also, this is pretty difficult to maintain, but could be done as a campaign.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Infographic of Outcomes
*hard (influence feature request: comment editing!)
Craig about 10 years ago
EditOn Easy to Share Graphics
can we surface community creative throug the creative collective
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Easy to Share Graphics
Would be nice to templatize these so they can be modular and updated as our goals change.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Quick Contribution
Love this!
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn 1 Day Campaign
Maybe this is too specific? Agreed with Holly that page should be able to live w/out a module like this.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn 1 Day Campaign
The page should be able to live without it
Brandon Arnold about 10 years ago
EditOn 1 Day Campaign
I like this, but a page shouldn't rely on it. Just in case we can't populate this the page it's on should still be awesome.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Choose What to Donate to
Should ask Andrea Wood how feasible this is?
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn 1 Day Campaign
I like but seems like a program we'd have to build WAY out. this is hard to nail and resouce right now. can it be a template we can turn on?
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Choose What to Donate to
Foundation team (Erika and Paul) do want to create a page about where donations go. Mike and I can take a next step to reach out to them on this one.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Choose What to Donate to
Talk with Andrea for help about quantifying/humanizing our donation dollars.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Choose What to Donate to
LIKE.
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Quick Contribution
We've explored something like this before and are continuing to explore it, would love to see it come to fruition.
Craig about 10 years ago
EditOn Goals and Progress
Progress BARS!!! where else can we have these?
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Help Wanted
We have been exploring ways to create an accessible "task board"
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Help Wanted
As long as it doesn't come across as us asking for free work. Contributors need to see the value in this for them.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Choose What to Donate to
I love this idea if we can make it work.
Craig about 10 years ago
EditOn Help Wanted
I think the "participation CTA" we are looking for on these pages are higher level - like buy a tshirt, share on facebook
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Help Wanted
Sean mentioned https://oneanddone.mozilla.org/en-US/
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Help Wanted
this is scary. that doen't mean NO. Just really intense to ask people to do big work without much vetting.
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Help Wanted
Not design a t-shirt or write the news letter. Share a news letter or buy a tshirt
Brandon Arnold about 10 years ago
EditOn Whole Page Sign-up
YES! and we'll have to make sure there's a conetent strategy and proram behind it that's contiguous
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn Whole Page Sign-up
Let's test?
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Whole Page Sign-up
I would think a big sign up with more context might work better?
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Contextual Sign-up
Yes!
Dia about 10 years ago
EditOn High Value Content - Emails
+1 about making the emails seem less spammy, more valuable. Need to talk with the team maintaining this.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Contextual Sign-up
100% agree that we want to collect more email addresses! We can't promise contextual.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Video and Impactful Headline
+1 to Craig's comments
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Choose What to Donate to
Notes from Andrea: We abandoned restricted giving because it's a nightmare to track and locks our $$ into specific things. So we don't want to go in this specific direction.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Choose What to Donate to
That said, we do want a a page that explains why mozilla raises money. And we want to try out "donate" CTAs in a variety of ways in the "participation" modules on the new pages.
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn What is Mozilla
I like the idea of a diagram, but would love to see something that shows how the pieces are connected to each other, not just to Mozilla.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla Is
I can see the limitations here, but conceptually it's stronger.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla is non-profit
Strategically it's bang on, but it's well-trodden territory. Would love to see a fresh exploration of this approach.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla Is
This is nice. A more creative version of the last one.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Fun Facts
I like do some of this here and there, but not a an overarching idea.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla Story
Not sure that the story represented here is exactly right, but I'm intrigued by this approach.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Changing Word
All I can add to the above is: Nice!
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Principles throughout
Could this be more subtle, almost like an easter egg? Depending on what page you're on, there could be some shapes or color coded dots to let you know which principles it speaks most to.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Global
We have used and do use maps a lot.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Following the Issues - Timeline
I think there's room/opportunity to use a timeline in some way, but maybe more as a history of the project.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Join the Conversation
Could this import Twitter conversations with a specific hashtag(s)?
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Who, What we do, What we make
Feels really overwhelming and complicated.
Matej about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla is non-profit
+1 to Matej's comment
Jen Bertsch about 10 years ago
EditOn Principles throughout
are these intended to be from the manifesto?
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Global
How is this different from Shape of the Web? That should be part of the site.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Region Specific Seciton
Not a priority right now.
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Connect with a Mozillian
I'm not sure where this fits in or the value it's providing
Anonymous about 10 years ago
EditOn Choose What to Donate to
Restricted giving might not work but I do love the idea of being more explicit about what the donations fund.
Paul Johnson about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla Is
+1 to limitations, but I still like the concept
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla is non-profit
This does less to communicate what we do
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla + You
With tangible examples, I can envision this really working
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Mozilla Story
I don't understand what's happening here.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Who, What we do, What we make
There is a lot going on here. I don't know where to focus.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn What We Do
This seems like a cleaner version of the last design. I'm able to focus more here.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Large Images and Quotes
Like this but where do CTAs fit?
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Values
Agree with Dia. This feels like the manifesto.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Principles throughout
Like the idea of sprinkling manifesto tidbits around the site.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Global
Seems like a lot of work to keep this updates. Especially if "issues" refers to policy in any way.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Success Stories
We'd have to be very careful about what the take credit for. So much of our advocacy and education work is part of coalitions.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Following the Issues - Timeline
I find it hard to feel excited about linear timelines.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Changing Word
Agree there's potential here.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Enlist Friends
I can't quite envision how this works, but def. interested in ideas to get more signatures.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn 1 Day Campaign
Agree. Love the idea but we don't have resources to follow through.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Choose What to Donate to
+1 to Paul's comment.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Goals and Progress
:D Dia! I like progress bars too.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Help Wanted
Good lord, this terrifies me. Are we equipped to connect Mozillians to resources?
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Whole Page Sign-up
I love clear CTAs so...+1!
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn High Value Content - Emails
Love ideas to improve emails.
ErikaD about 10 years ago
EditOn Contextual Sign-up
Love to take this as far as we can (I see Jen's comment above and realize there are probably limitations).
ErikaD about 10 years ago
Edit